11 October 2022

4. Conclusion

Microcredentials are an innovative pedagogy with incredible potential.  The varied roles, functions and benefits are considerable, not least in improving accessibility to and engagement with responsive, digestible chunks of education regardless of individual circumstances and learning styles.  It truly is a flexible approach to promoting and supporting ongoing learning, enabling individuals to keep abreast of current trends and information essential to their workplace, and building on this to attain qualifications akin to those of a tertiary institution. Establishment of formalised, universally accepted terminology, criteria and frameworks will further facilitate uptake, adoption and recognition of this style of education, as will ongoing empirical and longitudinal research.

In the surgical context, the development and delivery of surgical- and medical-specific microcredentials has a number of benefits beyond simply education.  It affords the potential for national and international collaboration between various medical colleges and health sectors, providing the opportunity to establish consistent approaches for commonly experienced and observed patient settings.  The hypothetical result of such collaboration would ideally lead to healthier, more respectful and collaborative working relationships within hospitals/medical settings and better patient outcomes, resulting in a healthier, happier society.  While undoubtedly a little naïve and wishful thinking on my part, developing easily accessible, digestible and affordable microcredentials could be a way to facilitate more consistency across the delivery of medical care, regardless of context or country.

As with all new things, education is at the core of implementing any new pedagogical or innovative approach, and, as such, suitability for the learner audience and learning environment must be kept at the forefront to ensure optimal learning experiences.  This is an exciting space and I look forward to watching its continued evolution. 

3. Evaluation of microcredential applicability to a surgical setting

Given this pedagogical approach is still in its infancy, combined with the current lack of consistent terminology and supportive/delivery frameworks, significantly more research is needed to better understand the ways in which this approach can be leveraged to:

  • support lifelong learning; 
  • responsively and proactively address gaps in knowledge; 
  • facilitate workforce upskilling and reskilling; 
  • equalise access to learning opportunities, regardless of socioeconomic situation; and
  • meet the needs of a continually changing educational, technological and societal climate.  
With this in mind, microcredentials have the potential to support a diverse learning cohort of differing demographics and educational needs (Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Desmarchelier, 2021; Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Lok et al., 2022).

Opportunities and benefits

The opportunities and benefits of delivering microcredentials to aspiring, trainee and qualified surgeons are many.  Although microcredentials currently lack standardised definitions, implementations or assessments, this affords the opportunity to shape how microcredentials could, and ideally should, look and behave within both surgical and broader medical educational settings, with the additional advantage of promoting a reputation as an educational leader at the same time (Hope, 2022).

There are five key benefits to the introduction of microcredentials within a surgical context.  Firstly, it overtly promotes and supports lifelong learning across a range of topics identified as beneficial to potential, new and established surgeons (Bryant, 2022; Desmarchelier, 2021; Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Healy, 2021; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022).  Secondly, in the case of the latter group, it facilitates ongoing compliance with CPD requirements in a manner well-suited to a time-poor cohort (Lok et al., 2022).  Thirdly, it provides a mechanism of ensuring baseline/consistent knowledge and approaches on particular topics and skills (McGreal & Olcott, 2022).  Fourthly, digital badging can be used in various digital communication and social media settings to communicate proficiency in a particular skill set/knowledge area (Bryant, 2022; Desmarchelier, 2021; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Lok et al., 2022). Lastly, provision of and exposure to meaningful, educationally robust, assessed microcredentials has the potential to increase and improve learner engagement with online (and other) learning opportunities (Healy, 2021).

Hotaling and Van Sumeren (2022) posit that microcredentials are a way to identify and address knowledge gaps via a flexible delivery method, and a means to equalise access to education more broadly.  They go on to state, ‘incorporation of microcredentialling schema into these new models will not only accelerate learner placement in jobs but also integrate industry standards and workplace competencies into curricula to better match job opportunities with employment opportunities’ (Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022, p. 36).  This premise has definite applicability to the surgical setting, as it would enable educators to ensure the surgical educational framework and ten competencies are not only incorporated into microcredentials, but can also be demonstrated and assessed for understanding, and then incorporated into a doctor’s daily practice.  In turn, this would enable hospitals to have an established baseline of performance expected of surgeons who are at different stages of their career.

The ability to expire credentials is both an advantage and a challenge.  The primary advantage is expiration provides a mechanism to ensure ongoing participation in keeping abreast of trends and advancements within the professional field (Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Jones-Schenk, 2018; Lok et al., 2022; Western University, 2022).  The challenge would be if there was an associated cost, which learners may resent and potentially see the microcredential as a revenue mechanism, rather than supporting ongoing learning opportunities (Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022).


Potential challenges

As with any new initiative, educational, technological or otherwise, there are a number of challenges to be considered.  First is the assumption of digital competence and confidence, particularly those stereotypically categorised as digital natives (Bennett, Maton, & Kervin, 2008).  Second is that the proposed method(s) of delivery will be agreeable to the learner and the organisation (McGreal & Olcott, 2022).  Third is whether the existing IT infrastructure of the organisation will support the creation, delivery and assessment of microcredentials, and the assumption that learners will have access to the required technology for its delivery (Healy, 2021; Jones-Schenk, 2018; McGreal & Olcott, 2022).  Last is creating a meaningful, portable digital badge that is issued upon success completion (Bryant, 2022; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Lok et al., 2022; McGreal & Olcott, 2022).  And, of course, educating learners at all stages of their career about the importance and benefits of engaging with such content in an ongoing fashion (Bryant, 2022; Desmarchelier, 2021).

There is currently a distinct lack of research around the use of microcredentials within the medical, and specifically surgical, educational setting.  Lok, Beyene, Awaisu, Woods and Kheir’s (2022) exploratory study into the use of microcredentials within the pharmacy setting has some interesting findings that could potentially be applied to the surgical setting.  Although an incredibly small, self-selecting, geographically diverse sample (11) was interviewed over the phone, it was agreed that there was a place for microcredentials to support and promulgate a rapidly changing knowledge base for those working within the pharmacy field.  The comparatively short time commitment involved to upskill was seen as positive, as was obtaining digital badges upon successful completion, which would facilitate quick assessment of someone’s skills and knowledge in particular areas.  Suggestions around academic integrity and engagement with specialists/experts within different areas were raised, to ensure educational rigour and relevance of the microcredentials (Lok et al., 2022).

Another, broader, challenge identified is the cost and time involved in developing microcredentials themselves.  Some research has considered ‘unbundling’ existing curriculum into bite-sized chunks, however, it was recognised that the cost of doing so frequently outweighed the benefit; in most instances, it would be simpler to develop the microcredential from scratch (Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Lok et al., 2022; McGreal & Olcott, 2022).  This would likely apply to the surgical setting, particularly in the example given of a hypothetical communication microcredential; while there is some existing online content, creating a suite from scratch to ensure consistency and currency would be more advantageous educationally.  


Ways to promote engagement and benefits

There are several ways in which the benefits of engagement with microcredentials could be delivered and promoted, the most important being the ongoing support of an individual’s lifelong learning journey in an ever-changing world.  The ability to deliver microcredentials online, face-to-face, or a combination of the two, ensures recognition and accommodation of different schedules and personal circumstances, learning preferences and learning styles of a diverse cohort (Desmarchelier, 2021; Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; McGreal & Olcott, 2022).

From the established surgeon’s perspective, microcredential participation provides the opportunity to not only refresh and further knowledge on a specific topic, it also meets CPD requirements, further incentivising active participation in, and completion of, microcredential activities.  From the perspective of an aspiring surgeon or recent medical graduate, microcredentials could provide a means of gaining further competence and confidence in specific areas (e.g. communication skills, basic surgical skills) and feel more ‘workplace ready’ (Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022).  More broadly, achieving and sharing digital badges is a neat way to promote skills and knowledge acquired and ongoing, advertising attainment of an educationally robust, assessed microcredential.


2. Explanation of applicability to a surgical educational context

Surgery is an incredibly competitive field, with surgical aspirants continually looking for opportunities to boost the likelihood of selection into a specialty training programme.  Offering a range of microcredentials targeted at different levels of skills and expertise is one way in which to support post-graduate doctors in their quest to specialise, be it in surgery or another medical specialty, as well as promoting and supporting lifelong learning to qualified surgeons.





Figure 1. Surgical pathway

During each of these stages of career progression (Figure 1; select image to enlarge), there are a range of educational activities that need to be completed in order to successfully progress to the next.  Once the mantle of Fellowship has been bestowed, it is at this stage the surgeon is required to participate in continuing professional development (CPD) activities in order to keep abreast of innovations and changes within the surgical space.  CPD activities include conferences, audits, events and courses, including eLearning (Royal Australasian College of Surgeons, n.d.).  It is in the latter category that microcredentials could have the most value.



Figure 2. Surgical microcredential considerations

Figure 2 (select image to enlarge) outlines the key considerations involved when assessing the potential application of microcredentials as another way to support upskilling and lifelong learning for this cohort.  The current paucity of research into microcredentials makes it difficult to adequately hypothesise success based on the current findings, not least because of the limited educational areas and applications explored to date.  Likewise, the lack of agreed upon pedagogical parameters (e.g. definitions, structures, frameworks and implementation), as well as how success can be measured, are further obstacles to be addressed (Desmarchelier, 2021; Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Healy, 2021; McManus, 2021; Oliver, 2021; Perkins & Pryor, 2021).  That said, with the Australian Government’s commitment to the development of a microcredential ‘marketplace’ (Desmarchelier, 2021; UAC, 2021; VOCEDplus, 2018), along with similar discussions in New Zealand (VOCEDplus, 2018), it is likely broad microcredential frameworks will be developed at some stage, with the potential for adaptation as required.  


Figure 3. Surgical microcredential components

Figure 3 (select image to enlarge) explores some of the key features that would likely be considered and/or incorporated during the development of a surgical microcredential.  Meaningful, relevant content would be delivered in small chunks to make successful engagement as convenient and accessible as possible, given the time constraints faced by those within the surgical space.  To better support different learning styles, asynchronous content could be completed sequentially or ad hoc, and could be stacked to create more substantial qualifications (Desmarchelier, 2021; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Jones-Schenk, 2018; McGreal & Olcott, 2022; Walsh, 2017). Measurable and assessable learning objectives would be established for each chunk, with feedback provided per assessment and a digital badge issued upon successful completion of the microcredential (Desmarchelier, 2021; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Jones-Schenk, 2018; Lok et al., 2022; McGreal & Olcott, 2022; McManus, 2021; Rimland, 2019). 



Figure 4.
Proposed structure for one surgical microcredential

Figure 4 (select image to enlarge) outlines the proposed chunks/topics of a hypothetical surgical microcredential in communication, a ‘soft’ skill that needs to be done well within the surgical setting (Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022).

1. Microcredentials and the surgical setting

Education can be a wild ride. In this continually changing world, where we all learn and access information in different ways and according to our own personal circumstances, pedagogical and technological innovations ebb and flow to support diverse groups of learners and learning styles. Microcredentials are one such example.

Microcredential: a brief overview  

Microcredentials are an emerging pedagogy with considerable applicability across a range of educational settings and learner audiences.  While there is no standardised definition as yet, microcredentials are broadly seen as a means of delivering chunked content on a specific topic to the learner, with multiple chunks making up a microcredential (Blannin, 2021; Desmarchelier, 2021; Desmarchelier & Cary, 2022; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; McGreal & Olcott, 2022; McManus, 2021; Western University, 2022).  

The premise is that microcredentials are an accessible way to support and further learning, as these can be undertaken more flexibly, and with less time and financial commitment than required from a traditional qualification (Bryant, 2022; Desmarchelier, 2021; Healy, 2021; Hotaling & Van Sumeren, 2022; Jones-Schenk, 2018; Lok et al., 2022).  Understandably, this is an attractive educational option for a broad range of institutions, organisations and sectors, as it has the potential to responsively address identified knowledge gaps while providing opportunities to engage with lifelong learning and professional development activities (Bryant, 2022; Hotaling & Van Sumeran, 2022; McManus, 2021).

This particular sequence of blog posts will consider the applicability of microcredentials as a means to support surgical lifelong learning.  For the sake of providing context/working examples, I will look at how this innovative pedagogy could be used to facilitate lifelong learning for a time-poor cohort.







4. Conclusion